Crossnacreevy Cob Condition Key

Maize recommended varieties | Maize variety search
The correct stage for harvesting a maize crop is when it has reached around 30-35% dry matter. Below 25% DM the crop has not reached its full production potential and effluent loss is a risk. Maturing the cobs above 35% DM, and particularly when above 40% DM, risks significant spoilage losses in the silo plus utilization becomes an increasing problem. Therefore, the most effective way of identifying how the crop is progressing towards harvest is to assess the change in condition of the cobs during the later part of the season.
There are a number of different guidelines and scoring systems available, which have different ways of identifying the ideal ‘30% total crop’ dry matter stage. Some of these can be very complex and although no doubt effective, are difficult to use without some degree of experience or training. Often the stages of development are hard to identify in practice and can also require some assessment of the size and greenness of the overall plant. In the hands of an expert, such systems are very effective and possibly more precise that the simple system provided below. The key below, however, is intended as a simple guide that is very easy to remember and use.
Crossnacreevy cob key  
Categories
Kernal condition
Value score
Watery milk
Water runs free, translucent kernals
0
Creamy milk
Creamy water and little or no solids
1
Starch forming
Milk > Starch
Midway =2
3
 
Milk = Starch
Midway =4
5
 
Milk < Starch
Midway =6
7*
Firm cheese
No free moisture, solid cheeder-like starch
8*
Hard flour
Hard dry floury Starch
9
[ < means less than, > means greater than]
*30 - 35% DM Harvest stage

Background information

This simple system of scoring cob maturity comprises only five main categories, which are visibly easy to distinguish and will help growers gage how quickly a maize crop is progressing towards harvest.
Watery milk: This is when the cobs are white and the juice runs freely out of the kernels when punctured with a fingernail.
Creamy milk: This is when the cobs are showing some cream to pale lemon colouring but when punctured with the fingernail, a cloudy juice runs freely from the kernel to leave little or no solids.
Starch forming: This is the most important category as it is when the maize plant is laying down starch and spans the period from early filling to the early stage of maturity when the kernel contains cheesy starch but still releases a little moisture when punctured. This category has been divided into three simple stages depending on the ratio of milk to starch in the kernel.
  1. Milk ‘greater than’ starch is when the cob is turning light yellow and there is still a lot of milky juice but there is also a little soft cheesy starch inside the punctured kernel.
  2. Milk ‘equal to’ starch is when the cob is a bright yellow colour and about half the kernel content is soft cheesy starch.
  3. Milk ‘less than’ starch is when the cob is a strong yellow colour and noticeably heavier than before. There will still be a little creamy moisture in the kernels but they contain almost entirely soft cheesy starch that sticks to the finger or remains inside the punctured kernel.
The ideal harvest mature stage of 30-35% dry matter content will occur during the next stage and speed of change and timing of harvest depends on the following conditions:
  • Firm cheese: This stage is when the kernels contain no free moisture. They are firm and require strong pressure to burst the kernel open with a fingernail to expose the cheddar-cheese-like starch. As this cheese-like starch continues to dry it looses its elasticity and it becomes more difficult to push a fingernail deep into the kernel.
  • Hard flour: This final stage is when the cobs are totally dry and cannot be burst with a fingernail. They have to be picked open with a thumbnail to reveal hard dry mealy flour. With time the cobs will develop a deep glazed almost orange sheen and become so hard that it is impossible to break into them manually.

Further background information

This simple scheme should be very easy to use and has given very good agreement between different users. Particularly during the important ‘Starch Forming’ category, it should be a simple task to decide whether or not there is more starch than milk in the kernels. Even if the kernels do not exactly fit the description above, there are midway scores that can be used to show this is the case.
As temperatures fall in October, so development changes slow down, but crops need to be checked frequently once Stage 7 (milk < starch) is reached. Once the cobs are internally dry it is expected that harvest should follow, though where an excessively large and green standing crop has been built up some delay may be reasonable to allow the rest of the plant to dry out. Care must be taken not to over mature the cobs towards Stage 9 (Floury) due to the associated spoilage and utilization risks plus the problem that a heavily senesced crop will have depressed ME levels. So the key stage for harvest is when the kernel is a firm ‘juiceless cheese’. If too hard and mealy and turning a glazed orange, it is over ripe and if milky when squeezed, then hold off harvesting a little longer to gain more starch and a higher dry matter.
Harvesting before the correct stage is unlikely to deliver any benefits other than a completion of the harvesting operation and is likely to sacrifice additional starch that the maize could have produced if allowed to stand longer.
This Crossnacreevy cob key is intended only as an aid to correctly timing of maize harvests. It will provide a reliable indicator of when it is safe to leave the crop growing on to mature further or when the crop will need to be closely watched and a harvest decision taken soon.