Is Beef Production From The Dairy Herd The Way Forward?
A
major Beef Open Day to be held at the Agri-Food and Biosciences Institute (AFBI) Hillsborough on Saturday
23rd September 2006 running from 10.00 am to 4.00 pm. Results from the latest research on the viability
of beef systems based on sourcing calves from the dairy herd will be among the topics highlighted.

Dr
Lynne Dawson (AFBI Project Leader, Beef Research) and Brian Dawson (AFBI Beef Technician) discussing
performance of Belgian Blue, Limousin, Aberdeen Angus and Holstein-Friesian calves at grass.
Currently,
52% of prime cattle slaughtered in Northern Ireland come from the suckler herd and 44% from the dairy
herd. The decoupling of subsidies from production is predicted to result in a decrease in beef production
from the suckler herd. This, together with the desire by dairy producers to increase income from calf
sales, is likely to result in an increased proportion of beef calves from the dairy herd. Whilst beef
cross dairy calves command a significant premium in price in the market place relative to Holstein bull
calves, it is important that the actual additional value of beef cross dairy calves to the beef finisher
is determined. A major research AFBI programme, funded jointly by AgriSearch and the Department of Agriculture
and Rural Development (DARD), has recently been initiated to evaluate the effect of beef calves from
the dairy herd when finished as either steers or bulls on:
Performance
Food
conversion efficiency
Meat quality
Economic
output
The research will also examine the impact
of using semen from beef bulls in the dairy herd on calving difficulty and subsequent performance and
fertility of the dairy herd.
There are major limitations
on labour availability on many farms in Northern Ireland. When moving from a suckler cow system where
the cow is responsible for rearing the calf, to a dairy-beef system, it is important to consider the
additional labour input associated with rearing calves. Therefore, if there is to be a move to sourcing
more calves from the dairy herd for beef production, research into labour efficiency must be considered
and a further aspect of the project will be to develop low labour systems for rearing dairy bred calves.
To
date, approximately 110 February/March born calves have been sourced from Holstein-Friesian herds across
Northern Ireland. The main breeds sourced were Belgian Blue, Limousin, Aberdeen Angus and Holstein-Friesian.
On arrival at AFBI Hillsborough, the calves were allocated to two rearing systems:
Low
Labour Feeding System (LLFS)– calves were housed and offered milk replacer once per day through group
feeders designed to feed 30 calves.
Standard Feeding System
(SFS)– calves were housed in groups of 4 and offered milk replacer twice per day via a bucket feed system.

Low
labour input systems have the potential to reduce labour inputs by two thirds
Preliminary
findings indicate that rearing system had no significant effect on calf performance, with calves reared
on the LLFS having similar live weight gains from the start of the trial until weaning (Table 1). There
were also significant labour savings associated with the LLFS (up to a 2/3rd reduction in labour inputs).
After weaning, calves on the LLFS were turned out to grass from early May onwards. Due to poor weather
conditions in the spring, calves on the LLFS had lower live weight gains from weaning until 3 months
of age, relative to those on the SFS, such that they were on average 23 kg lower live weight at 3 months
of age. However, by 5 months of age this difference had almost disappeared, with calves on the LLFS
weighing only 2 kg less than those on the SFS.
Initial
results also indicate that breed of calf had a significant effect on performance with Aberdeen Angus
and Belgian Blue cross calves exhibiting superior performance compared with Holstein – Friesian and
Limousin calves (Table 2).
The performance of the cattle
involved in this study will be followed through to slaughter with detailed records of food intake, food
conversion efficiency, live weight gains, carcass characteristics and meat quality.
Details
of other ongoing AFBI beef research projects, including the new Beef Suckler Research herd will also
be available at the Open Day. The Open Day will give all those interested in the beef industry the opportunity
to see at first hand research being undertaken to improve performance/reduce costs under local conditions.
Representatives from AFBI Stormont (veterinary research), CAFRE, DARD and the wider industry will also
be present to provide up-to-date information on key issues affecting the beef industry. Keynote speakers
will provide an insight into future markets for Northern Ireland beef, options for developing sustainable
suckler cow systems and genetic improvement for the beef industry.
Animal
Health and Biosecurity Measures.
All those attending
the Open Day must bring thoroughly cleaned and disinfected footwear for use throughout the event. Those
attending are also asked to wear clean clothes not previously or subsequently to be worn while in direct
contact with their own animals. Protective overalls and foot wear will be provided and everyone will
be requested to wear these throughout the event. Disinfectant mats and foot dips will be provided upon
entry to AFBI Hillsborough and use of these by everyone attending will be mandatory.
Table
1. Effect of rearing treatment on calf performance up to 5 months of age
Variables |
Rearing treatment Low Labour Feeding System |
Rearing treatment Standard Feeding System |
|
Start live weight (kg)
|
|
|
|
Start age (days)
|
|
|
|
Live weight at weaning (kg)
|
|
|
|
Incidence of disease (No of treatments per calf)
|
|
|
|
Labour input (mins/calf/day)
|
|
|
|
Live weight at 3 months
|
|
|
|
Live weight at 5 months
|
|
|
|
Live weight gain start to 5 months (kg/d)
|
|
|
Table
2. Effect of calf breed on performance up to 5 months of age
Variables |
|
|
|
|
|
Start live weight (kg)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Start age (days)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Live weight at weaning (kg)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Live weight gain start to weaning (kg/d)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Incidence of disease (No of treatments per calf)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Live weight at 3 months
|
|
|
|
|
|
Live weight at 5 months
|
|
|
|
|
|
Live weight gain start to 5 months (kg/d)
|
|
|
|
|
For
further information please contact Lynne Dawson or Francis Lively at AFBI Hillsborough on 028 9268 2484.